| 1999 | Luke Hagerty- Ball State / Chicago Cubs Jay Carpenter - Defiance College Joe Gomez - Defiance College Brian Brenner - Defiance College Ryan Mumy - Lenoir Ryne University |
2000 | Eric Sprague - Defiance College Christian Snavely- Ohio State / Toronto Blue Jays |
| 2001 | Marc Franz - Ball State University Tony Steffel - Ohio Northern University Kurt Kaufman - Adrian College |
| 2002 | Chayse Held - College Of Wooster Markus Black - Malone University / Heidelberg College Tony Black - Northwood University Josh Knipp - Case Western University |
| 2003 | Chad Billingsley - Los Angeles Dodgers / Philadelphia Phillies TJ Willison -John A. Logan JC / Owens CC |
| 2004 | Nate Mouser - North Alabama University Austin Keel - University of Dayton Bryan Flory - Bowling Green State University Dylan Hefflinger - Owens CC |
| 2005 | Julian Bostleman - Bowling Green State University Jordan Schultz - Owens CC Jon Niese- New York Mets / New York Yankees |
| 2007 | Tyler Burgoon - U. of Michigan / Seattle Mariners Cameron Stykemain- Niagara University |
| 2008 | Bryn Lehman - Otterbein College / Defiance College Adam Wagner - Niagara University |
| 2009 | Justin Hancock - Lincoln Trail Juco / San Diego Padres / Chicago Cubs / Hokkaido Nippon Ham Fighters Stephen Leskow - Defiance College |
2010
| Dace Kime- University of Louisville / Cleveland Indians
Aaron Helland- Defiance College
Corbin Stykemain - Niagara University / UNOH |
| 2011 | Eric Stapleton -Lincoln Trail JC / King University Gabe Vittorio - West Virginia University |
| 2012 | Anthony Kidston - University of Louisville / Kansas City Royals Shea Murray - The Ohio State University / Pittsburgh Pirates Tyler Batt - Ohio Northern University Joe Gentile - Hillsdale College Taylor Cooper - Cornerstone University / Indiana Tech University |
| 2013 | Robert Zeigler - University of Kentucky / Kent State University Weston Rivers - Lincoln Trial JC / Indiana St.
Wade Verhoff - OSU - Lima |
| 2014 | Dom Gentile - Lincoln Trail JC / Defiance College Austin Hancock - Olney JC / Lenoir Ryne Jacob Green- Defiance College / Lake Erie College Torrence Hicks - Defiance College |
| 2015 | Michael Hendricks - Miami U, Lee University Garrett Sierra - Olney JC/ Lakeland CC / Defiance College Ty Castillo - Tri C JC / Robert Morris Tyler Weaver -Defiance College |
| 2016 | Shay Smiddy / University of Louisville / Tampa Bay Rays Will Zeller - St. Francis University Tino Ramirez - Sinclair JC |
| 2017 | Bryce Borton-Lincoln Trail JC Austin Taylor-Lincoln Trail JC Santiago Ramirez - Tri-C CC/Indiana Tech |
| 2018 | Jackson Meter-Lincoln Trail JC Nick Rodriguez-Lincoln Trail JC Mitchell Spencer-Lincoln Trail JC / USC Upstate / Purdue Fort Wayne |
| 2019 | Blayne Robinson / University of Louisville / San Jacinto JC / Ohio State |
| 2020 | |
| 2021 | Dade Robinson / Owens Community College |
| 2022 | |